Browse our latest inventory and find the perfect SUV, sedan, pickup, hatchback, or convertible that matches your budget, needs, and driving style.
Browse Vehicles by Popular Makes
START SEARCHING FOR YOUR NEXT VEHICLE
SHOP OUR FEATURED CARS & BEST DEALS
Family-Owned Used Car Dealer — Islip Terrace, NY
At Fair & Square Automotive Group, we believe buying a used car should be simple, transparent, and stress-free. As a family-owned used car dealership proudly serving Islip Terrace, Bay Shore, Brentwood, Central Islip, and all of Long Island, we offer a carefully inspected used car inventory, flexible financing for all credit types, and a buying experience built on trust. Good credit, bad credit, no credit — you’re always welcome here.
Why Thousands of Long Island Drivers Choose Fair & Square Automotive Group
We’re not just another used car lot. We’re your neighbors — and we go above and beyond to make sure every driver leaves happy, protected, and confident in their purchase.
Support Local Business
When you buy from us, you’re investing in your Long Island community. We’re proud to be a locally rooted used car dealership.
Family Owned & Operated
We treat every customer like family. No pressure, no gimmicks — just honest, caring service from real people who live in your community.
GWC Certified Pre-Owned Vehicles
Every eligible vehicle in our used car inventory is backed by GWC Warranty — one of the nation’s most trusted certified pre-owned programs.
Support Local Business
When you buy from us, you’re investing in your Long Island community. We’re proud to be a locally rooted used car dealership.
Family Owned & Operated
We treat every customer like family. No pressure, no gimmicks — just honest, caring service from real people who live in your community.
GWC Certified Pre-Owned Vehicles
Every eligible vehicle in our used car inventory is backed by GWC Warranty — one of the nation’s most trusted certified pre-owned programs.
Support Local Business
When you buy from us, you’re investing in your Long Island community. We’re proud to be a locally rooted used car dealership.
Family Owned & Operated
We treat every customer like family. No pressure, no gimmicks — just honest, caring service from real people who live in your community.
GWC Certified Pre-Owned Vehicles
Every eligible vehicle in our used car inventory is backed by GWC Warranty — one of the nation’s most trusted certified pre-owned programs.
Good Credit, Bad Credit, No Credit
Everyone deserves reliable transportation. Our lending partners help buyers across all credit situations get approved quickly and fairly.
Vehicles Serviced Before Delivery
Every used car in our inventory is fully serviced and road-ready before it’s handed over to you. No surprises after purchase.
Top Brands at Our Islip Terrace Used Car Lot
At Fair & Square Automotive Group, we proudly offer a diverse used car inventory featuring dependable vehicles from trusted manufacturers. Our selection includes models from well-known brands such as:
Audi, BMW, Cadillac, Chevrolet, Dodge, Ford, GMC, Honda, Hyundai, Jeep, Kia, Lexus, Mercedes-Benz, RAM, Toyota, Volkswagen, and more.
Everything You Need — One Trusted Dealer
From browsing our used car inventory to financing, trade-ins, warranty coverage, and maintenance — Fair & Square Automotive Group is your one-stop automotive partner on Long Island.
Used Car Inventory
Browse our growing selection of quality, low-mileage used cars, SUVs, trucks, and more — all inspected, serviced, and fairly priced at our Islip Terrace used car lot.
Search used cars near Islip Terrace NY
Used Car Financing
Get fast loan approval through our trusted lending network — good credit, bad credit, or no credit. We work to find a used car loan that fits your budget and gets you approved the same day.
Warranty Options
Protect your investment with GWC Certified Pre-Owned coverage and our range of extended warranty options. Drive with confidence knowing you’re covered long after you leave the lot.
Sell or Trade Your Car
Ready to upgrade? Trade in your current vehicle for a fast, fair estimate and apply the value directly toward your next purchase — reducing your out-of-pocket cost.
In-House Auto Service & Repairs
Our on-site service department handles everything from routine oil changes and NYS inspections to mechanical repairs — at wholesale parts and labor rates available only to our customers.
Vehicle Inspection & Certification
Every car in our inventory goes through a free 120-point inspection before it’s offered for sale, ensuring you get a quality, road-ready vehicle — no hidden issues, no surprises.
Serving Islip Terrace, NY and Nearby Communities
Fair & Square Automotive Group is proud to be a trusted used car dealer in Islip Terrace, NY, serving drivers throughout Long Island and surrounding communities. Our dealership is conveniently located for customers in Bay Shore, Central Islip, Brentwood, East Islip, Bohemia, Bayport, Hauppauge, and nearby areas within a 25-mile radius.
Drivers across the region visit our used car dealership near Islip Terrace because of our reputation for affordable used vehicles, quality inventory, and flexible financing options for all credit situations. Whether you’re looking for a reliable commuter vehicle or upgrading to something larger for your family, our team is here to help.
At Fair & Square Automotive Group, we make the car buying process easy by allowing customers to browse our used car inventory online, apply for used car financing, and sell or trade their current vehicle quickly and conveniently. Every vehicle on our lot is inspected to ensure quality and reliability for drivers across the Islip Terrace area.
If you’re searching for a reliable used car dealership near Bay Shore, Central Islip, Brentwood, or Hauppauge, visit Fair & Square Automotive Group today and discover why so many local drivers trust us for their next vehicle.
Visit Fair & Square Automotive Group Today
If you’re looking for a trusted used car dealer near Islip Terrace, NY, visit Fair & Square Automotive Group today. Explore our used car inventory, apply for used car financing, or sell or trade your vehicle with confidence.
Our friendly team is ready to help you find the right vehicle at the right price. Contact us today or stop by our used car dealership in Islip Terrace, NY to experience a fair and hassle-free car buying process.
I recently purchased a car from Andrew and the entire experience was outstanding 5 star from start to finish. Andrew was honest, straightforward, and incredibly easy to work with. He presented the vehicle exactly as it was, no hidden issues or inflated claims. Everything was fair and transparent. I wouldn’t hesitate to buy from him again or recommend him to friends and family.
I recently bought a 2015 Jeep Grand Cherokee Overland (fully loaded) from this dealership, and I have to say — the experience was incredible. The entire sales team was super helpful, professional, and made the process smooth from start to finish. Thomas walked me through everything and made my first time buying from a used dealer feel easy and stress-free. He answered all my questions and made sure I was comfortable with every step. Gary was also great and made the experience even better. If you’re in the market for a used car, I definitely recommend checking this place out. Great service, great people, and an overall great buying experience!
Sold our 2014 Honda CRV to Andrew today, Sunday. Received an extremely fair deal after his thorough inspection. He will repair some issues making it a reliable and safe vehicle for the next owner. Extremely honest professional owner. Highly recommend selling or buying from this business.
Staff was friendly & knowledgeable. Very fast & personable. Our salesman Gary was so kind and very experienced in the automotive world. He treated my daughter with respect and care. Andrew, the owner was more than fair and very transparent with us. They made us feel like family. We highly recommend Fair & Square to anyone shopping for a used car.
I had a great experience at Fair & Square. Andrew and Aydin were very helpful during a stressful time when my car was totaled. After looking online and visiting many dealerships they gave us the best price around.
